Daily Market Comment – Year end flows hit dollar, but gold can’t capitalize


Marios Hadjikyriacos, XM Investment Research Desk
  • Greenback takes a hit in thin markets – a prelude to 2020?  
  • Gold unable to take advantage of weaker dollar and lower US yields
  • Calendar empty, scarce liquidity still a theme

No news is bad news for the US dollar

News flow in financial markets remains non-existent as things wind down heading into the New Year, but that hasn’t stopped investors from cutting their exposure to the US dollar, which continues to bleed amid year-end flows. Many argue that the broader narrative around the dollar is shifting, with a US-China ceasefire and a recovering global economy curbing its haven appeal heading into 2020, as US election uncertainty adds a political risk premium on the reserve currency.

While these are valid arguments, the real question is, where else outside of the US can investors ‘hide’? Replicating the dollar’s high-yielding but safe-haven status is a difficult task, and for all it’s troubles, the American economy is still miles better than stagnant Europe, low-yielding Japan, or volatile emerging markets in an unstable trade environment.

It’s also fruitful to remember how dramatically and quickly narratives can change. This time last year, the Fed had just raised rates again, the ECB had just stopped its QE program, and many strategists were once again calling for the dollar’s demise as other regions became more attractive. That didn’t turn out quite as expected.

To be clear, the argument is not that the dollar won’t lose in 2020. Rather, it’s that for the greenback to weaken substantially, several variables need to play out ‘as planned’, and that rarely happens. The trade truce has to hold, the global recovery theme needs to stay unscathed, the risk of a disorderly Brexit has to remain dormant, and the Democratic presidential nominee should be someone radical enough to inject significant uncertainty into the outlook.

Are gold bulls exhausted, or just taking a breather?

In the broader market, the most exciting move – or rather, the lack thereof – was in gold. Bullion prices remained more or less flat on Friday, even though both the US dollar and Treasury yields fell notably, a combination that typically boosts gold.

Since gold contracts are denominated in dollars, a weaker US currency makes gold ‘cheaper’ for investors using foreign currencies, hence boosting demand for the yellow metal. Similarly, the lower interest rates go, the more attractive gold becomes in comparison to other defensive, interest-bearing assets such as bonds. Hence, a falling dollar combined with falling yields is usually a good recipe for gains in gold.

The inability of the bulls to push bullion prices above the $1515 per troy ounce level, which was also a formidable resistance hurdle in recent months, is rather worrisome and perhaps indicative of some exhaustion in the recent upswing. That said, drawing conclusions about any move during the final days of the year is usually not a healthy proposition, as the latest ‘underperformance’ could also be a function of profit-taking and rebalancing following a remarkable year for gold, when prices rose almost 18%.

Calendar to stay empty, mind the liquidity risk

Economic releases will remain a rare commodity in the coming days. China’s official PMIs for December – due early on Tuesday – could attract some attention, but absent some major surprise they are unlikely to shake markets much.

Rather, the main theme could remain a lack of liquidity. With many traders away for the holidays and with several Asian, European, and American markets set to stay closed, liquidity will probably be in very short supply – making sharp price moves possible even without news. In particular, the risk of ‘flash crashes’ in currencies, like the one in the yen this time last year, is probably elevated.