Credit Suisse bondholders seek legal advice on AT1 wipe-out
By Naomi Rovnick, Chiara Elisei and Kirstin Ridley
LONDON, March 23 (Reuters) -Credit Suisse CSGN.S bondholders are seeking legal advice after the Swiss regulator ordered 16 billion Swiss francs ($17.5 billion) of Additional Tier-1 (AT1) debt to be wiped out under its rescue takeover by UBS UBSG.S.
These higher-yielding junior bonds emerged from the 2008-2009 crisis as a way to boost bank capital while shifting the risk of losses to investors and away from taxpayers.
Lawyers and dealmakers said the AT1s, which have dropped in value to just a few cents in the dollar following the move, are being traded by hedge funds in a so-called litigation play.
Here's a look at the potential for litigation.
WHY IS THIS A BIG DEAL?
The Swiss regulator's decision inverted the long-established seniority of bondholders over shareholders over the assets of a company in distress. Not only did bondholders expect protection, but UBS is paying $3.23 billion to Credit Suisse shareholders.
This angered some investors and has prompted lawyers to start investigating potential litigation.
Other AT1 bonds fell in price on Monday on fears about the prospect of losses should other banks get into difficulty.
The bonds in the $275 billion market are designed to be shock absorbers if a bank's capital levels fall below a threshold. They are then converted into equity or written off.
WHO IS INVOLVED?
Law firms including Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, Pallas Partners and Korein Tillery say they are speaking to prospective bondholder clients about bringing claims.
In a call on Wednesday, which drew more than 750 attendees, Quinn Emanuel raised the prospect of pursuing claims in Switzerland and elsewhere, sources with knowledge of the matter told Reuters.
One Paris-based manager of a debt fund that held Credit Suisse AT1s said he had been "spammed" with emails from lawyers.
IS THERE AN OPPORTUNITY?
Some distressed debt-type funds have been buying Credit Suisse's AT1s for a few cents on the dollar. The bonds were traditionally held by institutional investors.
Samuel Norris, special situations partner at law firm Ropes & Gray in London, said he had been instructed by a number of hedge funds interested in trading the debt on the back of litigation news.
But five European and UK-based asset managers, identified by fund tracker Morningstar as among the top 50 European holders of the debt, told Reuters they were reluctant to join a court case that could take years.
The owner of a Hong Kong-based distressed debt fund said he had been approached by U.S. law firms, but was not interested.
Facing any challenge could be Credit Suisse, its new owner UBS, Swiss regulator FINMA or the Swiss government.
WHAT HAVE THE SWISS SAID?
FINMA on Thursday defended its decision, saying the move was legally watertight because of both the bond prospectuses and emergency government legislation.
FINMA said the bonds contractually allow for a total write down in a 'viability event', "in particular if extraordinary government support is granted", which occurred when Credit Suisse was given "extraordinary liquidity assistance loans secured by a federal default guarantee".
It also cited an emergency March 19 ordinance which it said authorised FINMA to instruct Credit Suisse to write off the bonds.
Hong Kong, Singapore, the European Union and Britain all said this week they would stick to the traditional hierarchy of creditors claims in the event of a bank collapse.
HAS AT1 LEGAL ACTION HAPPENED BEFORE?
A dispute over the write-off of around $1 billion AT1s issued by India's Yes Bank YESB.NS in March 2020 after the Reserve Bank of India initiated a restructuring of the lender is currently subject to court proceedings.
In 2017, holders of Spain's Banco Popular stocks and AT1 bonds were wiped out when the bank was taken over by Santander, although bondholders lost out alongside the shareholders.
Bondholders took legal action against the regulator but have been so far unsuccessful.
DOES LITIGATION STACK UP?
Lawyers, bondholders and banking analysts have been poring over the bond documentation to see if it allowed for the wipe-out.
The Swiss government on Sunday said that FINMA had been "provided with a clearer legal basis so that part of Credit Suisse's regulatory capital can be written off". FINMA believes both the contracts and the emergency ordinance are on its side.
But some lawyers are undaunted, although none thinks a claim would be resolved quickly.
London-based Pallas Partners said it was working on possible legal action with Swiss peers. Four other lawyers in London said they were also examining the potential for lawsuits - some on behalf of both bondholders and shareholders.
($1 = 0.9164 Swiss francs)
Central banks keep hiking rates amid banking turmoilnL1N35V0RR
Swiss regulator defends its decision to write off AT1 bondsnL8N35V1AV
Hedge funds eye opportunities in cut-price Credit Suisse AT1snL1N35U02A
Credit Suisse AT1 bondholders consider possible legal action -law firmnL1N35S2WN
EXPLAINER-Why markets are in uproar over a risky bank bond known as AT1nL8N35S37F
Reporting by Naomi Rovnick, Chiara Elisei, Kirstin Ridley, Tommy Reggiori Wilkes, Marc Jones, Pablo Mayo Cerqueiro and Davide Barbuscia; Writing by Dhara Ranasinghe and Tommy Reggiori Wilkes, Editing by Alexander Smith
면책조항: XM Group 회사는 체결 전용 서비스와 온라인 거래 플랫폼에 대한 접근을 제공하여, 개인이 웹사이트에서 또는 웹사이트를 통해 이용 가능한 콘텐츠를 보거나 사용할 수 있도록 허용합니다. 이에 대해 변경하거나 확장할 의도는 없습니다. 이러한 접근 및 사용에는 다음 사항이 항상 적용됩니다: (i) 이용 약관, (ii) 위험 경고, (iii) 완전 면책조항. 따라서, 이러한 콘텐츠는 일반적인 정보에 불과합니다. 특히, 온라인 거래 플랫폼의 콘텐츠는 금융 시장에서의 거래에 대한 권유나 제안이 아닙니다. 금융 시장에서의 거래는 자본에 상당한 위험을 수반합니다.
온라인 거래 플랫폼에 공개된 모든 자료는 교육/정보 목적으로만 제공되며, 금융, 투자세 또는 거래 조언 및 권고, 거래 가격 기록, 금융 상품 또는 원치 않는 금융 프로모션의 거래 제안 또는 권유를 포함하지 않으며, 포함해서도 안됩니다.
이 웹사이트에 포함된 모든 의견, 뉴스, 리서치, 분석, 가격, 기타 정보 또는 제3자 사이트에 대한 링크와 같이 XM이 준비하는 콘텐츠 뿐만 아니라, 제3자 콘텐츠는 일반 시장 논평으로서 "현재" 기준으로 제공되며, 투자 조언으로 여겨지지 않습니다. 모든 콘텐츠가 투자 리서치로 해석되는 경우, 투자 리서치의 독립성을 촉진하기 위해 고안된 법적 요건에 따라 콘텐츠가 의도되지 않았으며, 준비되지 않았다는 점을 인지하고 동의해야 합니다. 따라서, 관련 법률 및 규정에 따른 마케팅 커뮤니케이션이라고 간주됩니다. 여기에서 접근할 수 있는 앞서 언급한 정보에 대한 비독립 투자 리서치 및 위험 경고 알림을 읽고, 이해하시기 바랍니다.